My boyfriend and I were in Potsdam for his work and was looking for a place to eat for dinner. It was a Monday evening and lots of places were closed. Came across Mama Lucia on Yelp and thought we could try out their pizza. I'm so glad we did bc the pizza was really good. We ordered a large pizza (half Capri and half Palermo) and a half size of Caesar salad. The pizza came out perfect when we picked it up. It was hot and they were able to give us takeout boxes to use as plates. When we got back to the hotel, pizza was still hot. They put a good amount of cheese on the pizza. I liked the Capri over the Palermo because it had a nice flavor of both basil and garlic. The Caesar salad was good too as they put a lot of shredded parmesan cheese and included these baked bread topped with cheese and garlic (their version of croutons). Inside of the restaurant was also very nice and it was nice to see people trickling in at opening. There were lots of tables and the ambiance was cozy. I recommend this restaurant as we were happy with our pizza and salad.

Best calamari I've had in years! Seafood Alfredo was excellent! Everything was fresh and cooked perfectly. Nice calming and interesting atmosphere. Friendly staff. I've found my new favorite place!

Delicious food and good portions. Server seemed new but was friendly and attentive. Patio was nice and quiet, great place to dine outside.

Every time we are in the area we dine at Mama Lucia's. The restaurant is an old train depot and really neat inside. The service and attention to detail are appreciated. L.j. & the staff always take such good care of us. They even accommodate large takeout orders for our son's college baseball team when we play other schools in the zip code. The food is amazing-HUGE homemade meatballs- warm homemade bread- a great selection of all your Italian favorites. Good drinks- great food a top notch service. Check it out!

We had our rehearsal dinner at Mama Lucia' for our October 2023 wedding and it was amazing! The staff did a great job making sure everyone was taken care of and having a good time, the food was delicious, and it was a really reasonable cost considering we were a group of 75! I would absolutely recommend for large-group dining! The manager who handles large group dining was incredible, so kind and organized and fun to work with. Mama Lucia's is now on our must-visit list for life everytime we are back in the North Country.

I came in from out of town and was given Mama Lucia's as a recommendation. We sat in the patio behind the building and it was quite nice. Even though there is a busy thoroughfare behind the restaurant, they have nice foliage around the patio that blocks the sight and sounds. My coworker ordered the Milan wood fired pizza, and I had the Cheri's lemon pesto chicken with a side of broccoli. We waited about an hour for our food, which is horrible. Despite that, our waitress, Alessandra, was very friendly and helpful. The lemon chicken was tasty with a light citrus flavor and capers. Unfortunately, the dish didn't come with many pieces of ravioli. It definitely needed more to compliment the amount of chicken you get. The side of broccoli was good, but it was huge and filled most of my to go plate. I understand the restaurant is family style, but it'd be nice if there was a smaller size serving available for veggies. My coworker demolished his pizza, so it must've been very good. Despite the very lengthy wait time, I would come back to eat here if I'm ever back in the area.